The Coleby Cup is named after one of the clubs former presidents J. Coleby.
Highest number of victories
| Name | Number of Victories |
|---|---|
| G. J. Bromley | 5 |
| A. Roberts | 3 |
| A. P. Davies | 3 |
| M. E. Williams | 3 |
| C. Buckley | 3 |
| S. Lloyd | 3 |
At the 2003 AGM, a decision was made to change the format of the Coleby Cup to an All-Play-All open tournament to be played in the summer. In the seasons prior to this in the late 1990’s it was run between January and May and was restricted to the novice players at the club. From 2005 onwards the competition has been run as a 5 round Swiss open to all.
Cup Winners
| Year | Winner | Year | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1963 | J. Coleby | 1990 | L. Ellis |
| 1964 | W. B. Turner | 1991 | |
| 1965 | D. R. Ellis | 1992 | |
| 1966 | L. Burdekin | 1993 | T. L. Finn |
| 1967 | A. Hughes & J. H. Walmsley | 1994 | B. hannan |
| 1968 | J. Coleby | 1995 | |
| 1969 | G. J. Bromley | 1996 | T. McKay |
| 1970 | L. R. Ainsworth | 1997 | A. Roberts |
| 1971 | L. R. Ainsworth | 1998 | A. Roberts |
| 1972 | 1999 | S. Lloyd | |
| 1973 | 2000 | A. Roberts | |
| 1974 | 2001 | G. M. Townsend & S. Lloyd | |
| 1975 | R. Clark | 2002 | G. M. Townsend |
| 1976 | A. L. Bradshaw | 2003 | G. J. Bromley |
| 1977 | R. Clark & M. P. Townsend | 2004 | S. Lloyd |
| 1978 | A. P. Davies | 2005 | G. J. Bromley |
| 1979 | A. P. Davies | 2006 | M. Lee |
| 1980 | A. P. Davies & M. E Williams | 2007 | M. Demmon |
| 1981 | M. E. Williams | 2008 | R. Walker |
| 1982 | M. E. Williams | 2009 | H. Bullard |
| 1983 | N. D. Bushnell | 2010 | D. Bryan |
| 1984 | G. J. Bromley | 2011 | R. Valantinas & R. Pearson |
| 1985 | G. J. Bromley | 2012 | J. Smith |
| 1986 | 2013 | C. Buckley | |
| 1987 | 2014 | C. Buckley | |
| 1988 | 2015 | C. Buckley & R. Yesudian | |
| 1989 | 2016 | M. McDonagh | |
| 2017 | P. Crocker & B. Roberts | ||
| 2018 | P.Crocker | ||
| 2019 | M. McDonagh |